Local News & Politics
Monmouth County Election Results 2026: 5 Key Takeaways
The Monmouth County election results 2026 produced one of the biggest local political shifts New Jersey saw on Election Day. Democrats won both available seats on the Monmouth County Board of Commissioners and captured the county surrogate’s office, breaking an 18-year drought in countywide elections.
The results remained unofficial Wednesday morning pending final certification, with 484 of 485 election districts reporting in the surrogate race. But the outcome was clear enough to change the makeup of county government when the new terms begin in January.
Here are five key takeaways from Tuesday’s vote.
1. Democrats Break an 18-Year Countywide Drought
For the first time since 2008, Democrats won countywide office in Monmouth County.
Democratic commissioner candidates Chelsey Tanner and Sofia Ugarte won the two seats on the ballot, defeating Republican Commissioner Erik Anderson and Middletown Mayor Tony Perry, who was seeking the seat being vacated by retiring Commissioner Ross Licitra.
Tanner led the field with 115,713 votes, followed by Ugarte with 114,049. Anderson had 111,332 votes in the latest reported totals.
The victory does not give Democrats control of the five-member Board of County Commissioners. Republicans will still hold a 3-2 majority beginning in January.
Still, the result marks a significant change. Republicans had held all five commissioner seats since 2011, and Democrats had not won any countywide race in Monmouth since John D’Amico won a freeholder seat in 2008.
That makes the Monmouth County election results 2026 notable beyond any single candidate. Voters restored a two-party presence to county government after years of complete Republican control of the board.
2. Anthony Cherry Wins the Monmouth County Surrogate Race
Democrats also won the race for Monmouth County surrogate.
Democratic attorney Anthony Cherry defeated Republican incumbent Maureen Raisch, who was seeking a second five-year term.
With 484 of 485 election districts reporting, Cherry had 115,552 votes, or 51.04 percent. Raisch had 110,614 votes, or 48.86 percent, a difference of 4,938 votes.
The surrogate’s office handles important legal matters involving the probate of wills, estates, adoptions, guardianships and certain trust matters involving minors and incapacitated adults.
Cherry’s victory was another important part of the countywide shift because it unseated an incumbent Republican in a county Donald Trump carried by 11 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election.
The contrast also shows why local elections cannot always be read through the results of a presidential race. Candidate strength, turnout and local concerns can produce a very different map two years later.
3. Fair Haven and Keyport Choose New Mayors
The political changes extended into several Monmouth County municipalities.
In Fair Haven, Democratic Councilwoman Michal DiMiceli won the mayor’s race with 1,170 votes. Republican Council President Elizabeth “Betsy” Koch received 1,068, while independent candidate Diana Anttonen received 736.
Democrats Marian Croak and Christopher Rodriguez also won the two Borough Council seats on the ballot.
Republicans entered Election Day with a 4-2 council majority. The new results leave the council divided 3-3, with DiMiceli able to break ties as mayor.
Keyport also elected a new mayor.
Democratic Councilwoman Kathleen McNamara defeated Republican Mayor Rose Araneo by 1,447 votes to 1,187.
Democrats Danielle Mastropiero and Robert Bergen also won council seats, giving the party the mayor’s office while preserving its 5-1 majority on the Borough Council.
Keyport has been competitive politically in recent years. Trump carried the borough in 2024, while Democratic Gov. Mikie Sherrill narrowly carried it in 2025. Tuesday’s results continued that pattern of voters moving between parties depending on the race.
4. Belmar Gives Caitlin Donovan a Full Term
In Belmar, voters gave Democratic Mayor Caitlin Donovan a full term.
Donovan defeated Republican Councilman Mike DeBlasio by 1,503 votes to 1,083.
Democrat Johanna Roper-Robinson also won the open Borough Council seat, defeating Republican Suzanne Anan 1,436 to 1,124.
Donovan became mayor earlier in 2026 after the Borough Council selected her to complete the remaining months of former Mayor Gerald Buccafusco’s term following his July 1 resignation.
Tuesday’s election gave Donovan a mandate of her own rather than an appointed term.
The results also prevented Republicans from taking complete control of Belmar’s municipal government after the party gained a 4-1 Borough Council majority in 2025.
5. Eatontown Stays With Anthony Talerico
Not every race brought a change in leadership.
In Eatontown, Democratic Mayor Anthony Talerico Jr. won a third term, defeating Republican Councilwoman Maria Grazia Escalante by 2,913 votes to 1,428.
Democratic Councilmembers Candace Faust and Danielle Jones also won reelection, preserving Democratic control of the borough government.
The Eatontown campaign unfolded during a major period of redevelopment for the borough, with the future of Fort Monmouth and funding connected to Netflix’s planned studio complex among the issues receiving attention.
For residents, those questions are likely to remain important well beyond Election Day as redevelopment moves forward.
What the Monmouth County Election Results Mean for 2027
The Monmouth County election results 2026 did not turn the county into a one-party stronghold.
Republicans will continue to control the Board of County Commissioners by a 3-2 margin. They also retained power in several municipalities, including Middletown, where Republicans Ryan Clarke and Morganne Dudzinski won the two Township Committee seats on the ballot.
What changed Tuesday was the political balance.
Democrats will enter 2027 with two seats on the county commission, control of the surrogate’s office and mayoral victories in several local communities. Republicans remain the majority party in county government, but they no longer hold every seat on the commissioner board or every countywide office.
That is the most important takeaway from Tuesday.
Monmouth County remains politically competitive.
The final certified vote totals may move slightly as remaining ballots are processed, but the larger result is already apparent: voters changed the makeup of county government and several municipal governments at the same time.
For a county where Democrats had gone 18 years without a countywide victory, Election Day 2026 was a significant break from the recent past.
Eva Braun
March 8, 2026 at 2:48 pm
Congrats to you Tom!